UNIQUE CHALLENGES FACED BY WOMEN PRISONERS IN INDIA: BEYOND THE BASICS BY - P.LAVANYA
UNIQUE CHALLENGES FACED BY WOMEN
PRISONERS IN INDIA: BEYOND THE BASICS
AUTHORED BY - P.LAVANYA
B.A., B.L.(Hons), LLM.,
Part-time Ph.D research
scholar in TNDALU, Chennai
Advocate at Madras High
Court.
Abstract:
The conditions for women in prisons, both as undertrials and convicts,
have received insufficient attention, particularly within the human rights
sphere. Despite the creation of a Model Prison Manual (2016) at the national
level to address these issues, the actual conditions for women in Indian jails
remain far from the ideal standards outlined in the manual. In India, the
Mental Health Care Act was enacted on April 7, 2017, and object of this act was
the decriminalization of attempted suicide, which had been an offense under
Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code.
Ongoing monitoring and reforms are necessary to improve the treatment and
environment for female inmates across the country. In addition to the general
challenges faced by all prisoners, women in India face unique challenges due to
their gender. These challenges can be exacerbated by mental health issues, such
as Postpartum Blues (Baby Blues), Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder (PMDD),
Postpartum Depression, Perinatal Mental Health Issues, Perimenopausal and
Menopausal Depression, Intimate Partner Violence-related Mental Health Issues,
Body Image Issues, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and perinatal mental
health issues, etc.
Introduction
Jails
have traditionally been designed with male inmates in mind, which often leads
to institutional neglect when it comes to addressing the needs of female
prisoners. To ensure proper conditions for women, it is essential to take specific
measures, particularly independent visits and regular monitoring. Female
inmates frequently encounter prison infrastructure and administrative systems
that fail to recognize their gender-specific needs. Despite the growing number
of women in prisons, the infrastructure has not kept pace with this increase,
resulting in inhumane treatment of female prisoners.
The
situation of women in prisons, whether they are convicted or awaiting trial,
has received limited attention. There seems to be little concern from elected
officials or the public, and the families of incarcerated women often feel
powerless.
History and Background
In 1987,
the Justice Krishna Iyer Committee was the first to examine the situation of
women in prisons, nearly four decades after India gained independence. The
committee recommended increasing the number of women in the police force,
particularly to address crimes involving women and children. It also created a
draft Model Prison Manual, which included special provisions for the children
of female prisoners. This manual was shared with states and Union Territories
to be included in their own prison guidelines.
Notably,
the committee made important recommendations regarding the rights of pregnant
prisoners, including the conditions for childbirth in prison. It also suggested
guidelines for how long children can stay with their mothers in prison, their
care through crèches and nurseries, and the provision of suitable clothing for
different climates. The committee emphasized regular medical check-ups, access
to education and recreational activities, and adequate nutrition for both
children and nursing mothers.
Ten years
later, in 1997, the Supreme Court instructed the central government to create a
national prison manual. This was eventually completed in 2003, when the
government distributed it to all states and Union Territories, urging them to
adopt it.
In 2016,
the Supreme Court issued a significant judgment on the inhumane conditions in
1,382 prisons across India. The main issues raised in the case included
overcrowding, unnatural deaths of prisoners, lack of staff, and inadequate
training of staff. After reviewing the state governments’ responses, the court
criticized the lack of genuine action and the superficial steps taken by the
states to address these problems. Despite funds being allocated for prison
improvements under the 13th Finance Commission, many states failed to use these
funds, and in some cases, no funds were allocated at all.
The
updated Model Prison Manual of 2016 was a result of the Supreme Court's
intervention, replacing the older 2003 version. The new manual includes
provisions to protect the rights of women prisoners, including measures to
prevent undertrials from remaining in prison due to lack of legal support or
bail. It also provides special guidelines for women and their children in
prison, which need to be implemented by states and Union Territories.
The
Ministry of Home Affairs in India has officially reported that only 11 states
and Union Territories have adopted the Model Prison Manual so far. Other states
continue to manage their prisons according to their own state-level prison
manuals, which are based on the Prison Act of 1984. These manuals may not
always fully address the rights of women prisoners. Apart from a few states
like Odisha, Goa, and Delhi, most states have yet to adopt the Model Prison
Manual developed by the Bureau of Police Research and Development (BPRD). Since
prisons fall under state jurisdiction, it is the responsibility of individual
states to ensure their prison rules comply with national laws and
constitutional rights. However, prisons remain one of the most overlooked
sectors, with limited reform efforts.
Motto of the Mental Health Care Act 2017
·
The Mental Health Care Act of
2017 focuses on decriminalizing suicide attempts, emphasizing the importance of
rehabilitation for individuals who attempt suicide rather than subjecting them
to legal action. This approach aims to provide necessary support and care from
the government.
·
The Act also aligns with India's
commitments under the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
and its Optional Protocol.
·
A significant shift from the
Mental Health Act of 1987, the 2017 legislation aims to empower individuals
with mental illness by recognizing their ability to make informed decisions
regarding their health, provided they possess the necessary understanding.
·
In addition to safeguarding the
rights of people with mental health issues, the Act ensures non-discriminatory
access to healthcare and treatment. It also mandates that insurers offer
medical coverage for mental health treatment on the same terms as physical
illnesses.
·
The 2017 Act introduces the
registration and regulation of mental health institutions. It also requires the
establishment of more mental health facilities nationwide, so individuals do
not need to travel long distances to access care. Furthermore, a Mental Health
Review Board has been created to oversee and regulate the sector.
·
Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)
is now restricted to emergency cases and must be performed with muscle
relaxants and anesthesia. The use of ECT as a treatment option for minors has
been entirely prohibited.
·
The 2017 Act also clarifies the
responsibilities of other agencies, such as law enforcement, in relation to
individuals with mental illness.
·
Moreover, the Act seeks to combat
the stigma associated with mental health and outlines strategies to address and
reduce this societal challenge.Top of
Form
According
to the 31st December 2021 report by the National Crime Records
Bureau (NCRB), of the 554,034 prisoners in India, 531,025 were male, 22,918
were female, and 91 were transgender. This data indicates a significant female
prison population, yet their issues continue to go largely ignored and Bottom of Form
and the occupancy rate in women’s prisons was 56.3%.
There were 32 women’s jails with a total capacity of 6,767, but only 3,808
women were actually incarcerated there, including 5 transgender inmates. In
other types of prisons (non-designated women’s jails), there was a capacity for
22,659 women, but the actual number of women prisoners was 19,115, resulting in
a much higher occupancy rate of 84.4%.Top
of Form
Female
Occupancy Rate as per the NCRB Report:
- Uttarakhand: 178.8%
- Bihar: 152.3%
- Chhattisgarh: 147.6%
States
with the Highest Number of Female Inmates:
- Uttar Pradesh: 4,995 women
- Bihar: 3,067 women
- Madhya Pradesh: 1,892 women
a) Number of
Women Jails in India: Only 15 states and Union
Territories have women-only jails. In that Rajasthan has the highest number,
with 7 women-only jails. Tamil Nadu follows with 5, and Kerala has 3. Andhra
Pradesh, Bihar, Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, and Delhi each have 2 women-only jails.
Karnataka, Maharashtra, Mizoram, Odisha, Punjab, Telangana, and West Bengal
each have just one women-only jail.
b) Occupancy
Rate in Jails: The national occupancy rate in central jails for
female prisoners was 91.5% by the end of 2021. In district jails, the occupancy
rate for women was 107.2%. In sub-jails, the occupancy rate for women was much
lower at 27.1%.
c) Overcrowding
in Women’s Jails: Bihar had the highest
overcrowding in women’s jails with an occupancy rate of 115.8%. Other states
with high overcrowding were Maharashtra (109.2%) and Telangana (108.8%).
Women Prisoners’ Rights and Safety Measures
Right to health:
All prisoners are to be vaccinated upon admission,
and special care is to be provided for elderly prisoners and those with drug addiction
problems. Prison authorities should be aware that many women enter prison with
pre-existing physical or mental health conditions due to a lack of awareness
and resources in society. These conditions often require medical attention. The
National Prison manual calls for comprehensive health screenings for female
prisoners, which should include tests for sexually transmitted diseases,
blood-borne diseases, mental health issues, drug dependency and for inspecting
the mental health of inmates and offering counselling, therapy, or recommending
transfer to specialized facilities when needed. Women who need treatment for
mental health issues should not be kept in prisons but should be placed in
separate facilities, like mental health hospitals. Women in prison also face
numerous difficulties, including poor infrastructure and overcrowding. Basic
facilities such as electricity, fans, and clean bathrooms are often lacking.
On June
25, 2018, Union Minister for Women and Child Development, Maneka
Sanjay Gandhi, released a report titled ‘Women in Prisons’. The report
highlights the challenges women face in prisons, their rights, and potential
solutions to improve their conditions. The report points out that despite
guidelines in state manuals, the physical and mental health of female prisoners
often suffers. In many prisons, there are no female wards in hospitals, and
gynecologists or lady medical officers are unavailable. Mental health concerns
are also often overlooked, and women with mental health issues are sometimes
kept in prisons due to the lack of appropriate care facilities. Women's health
needs, including physical, mental, sexual, and reproductive health, require
specific attention for re-socialized and re-educated.
Thus Ministry
of Home Affairs has recognized that good health not just the absence of
disease but also a sense of well-being and happiness. For example, in Gujarat's
Sabarmati women's jail, there is only a small dispensary with a health worker.
There are no facilities for urgent medical care or mental health support. The
absence of medical staff during holidays and at night often delays necessary
treatment, sometimes with fatal consequences.
According
to the 2016 National Prison Manual, the health screening of women
inmates should respect their privacy and dignity, and ensure medical
confidentiality. Women should not be forced to share their reproductive health
history or undergo screening without consent. The manual also calls for
transferring women with mental health issues to specialized care facilities
rather than keeping them in prison. Moreover, continuity of care should be
ensured, and support should be provided to women after their release to help
them continue receiving treatment.
In May
2017, the Supreme Court highlighted the severe shortage of staff in jails
across the country. It directed state governments and Union Territories to
urgently fill these vacancies by December 31, 2017. Inspections by the National
Human Rights Commission (NHRC) of over 100 jails found a significant
lack of staff, especially in smaller district prisons. There is an increasing
need for dedicated women’s prisons, trained female prison officers, full-time
female doctors, and pediatricians to address the specific needs of women
prisoners.
Right to Food
& Nutrition: Nutrition is essential for good
health, and the prison manuals of each state set guidelines for the daily
calorie and nutritional intake for inmates. Women who are pregnant or
breastfeeding require additional nutrition, including more protein, minerals,
milk, sugar, vegetables, fish or meat, curd, and fresh fruits. Any complaints
about food should be reported to the prison superintendent. However, the
reality is quite different. For example, at Gujarat’s Sabarmati Women’s Jail,
only two meals are served: one at 9 AM and another at 5 PM. The food is often
cold, and the quality control is questionable. In reviewing the Mulla
Committee recommendations, the Ministry of Home Affairs pointed out that dining
areas are often the most neglected parts of prisons.
Pregnant
and nursing women require additional nutrients to ensure both their own health
and that of their children. According to general nutritional guidelines, pregnant
and nursing women need around 3100 calories per day, with an increased intake
of protein and minerals. The extra protein can be obtained by substituting a
portion of cereal in the diet with milk, fish, meat, and eggs, or for
vegetarians, focusing on milk and dairy products. Additionally, these women
need an adequate supply of minerals to maintain their health and support the
fetus or infant. Without this, both the mother and child face serious health
risks.
Lack of Facilities for Children in Prison
While
Tihar Jail has set a positive example, many other prisons, especially in states
like Punjab and Gujarat, continue to neglect the needs of children of
incarcerated women. In Punjab, children receive less than two spoons of milk
powder per day, and there are no nurseries or playgrounds available for these
children to ensure their physical and emotional development. Additionally,
though children are allowed to visit their incarcerated mothers, the lack of
adequate facilities for their comfort and well-being remains a significant
issue.
A
pregnant woman or lactating mother might receive one fruit and a sachet of milk
per day, but the quality and quantity of these provisions are not regularly
monitored. Furthermore, the snacks and food provided to children are sporadic
and insufficient, leading to nutritional deficiencies. This lack of monitoring
points to a critical need for improved oversight and accountability in the
provision of basic needs.
Supreme Court Guidelines and Implementation
The
Supreme Court's guidelines, particularly from the R.D. Upadhyay v. State of
Rajasthan (2006) case, laid down specific directives for the care of children
in prisons and the needs of incarcerated women. These guidelines address
essential aspects such as the provision of:
- Crèches for
children up to six years old under Maternity Benefit Act 2017
- Adequate diet,
clothing, and medical care for children
- Access to education for
the children of women prisoners
- The possibility for children
above six years to be sent to boarding schools outside the prison
for better care and schooling.
In Delhi's
Tihar Jail, the guidelines are reportedly being followed, with crèches and
necessary support provided for children up to six years old. However, the
implementation and availability of these facilities are not consistent across
all prisons in India.
Education and Vocational Training
The
National Prison Manual provides educational opportunities for inmates based on
their educational background and interests. Education for young offenders (ages
18-21) who are illiterate is considered mandatory. A 2018 report on women in
prisons by the Ministry of Women and Child Development reveals that many
prisons fail to provide education for women. Higher education is rarely
accessible, and even in prisons with libraries, women prisoners often cannot
use them. The lack of staff, resources, and planning makes it difficult to
offer education.
For
example, in Ahmedabad's Sabarmati Women's Jail in 2022, there is no literacy
training available. The only work opportunity for women is in a sanitary pad
manufacturing facility, where they work from 10 AM to 5 PM for a daily wage of
Rs 70-90, far below the minimum wage. Before the Covid-19 pandemic, there were
classes in journalism and yoga, but now only beauty parlour and embroidery
training are available. While official reports claim that a leading NGO
provides trained female teachers for the education of women in Gujarat's
prisons, this is not the case in Ahmedabad. The lack of marketable skills and
limited vocational options for women prisoners can be seen as a significant
barrier to their rehabilitation and reintegration into the workforce. There are
some barriers hinder them to achieve the set goal:
- Limited Funding
- Lack of Market Relevance
- Gender-Specific Needs
Legal aid
Legal aid
helps to level the playing field, especially for those who may not have the
financial resources to hire private lawyers, thus promoting equality before the
law. It is a fundamental right for all individuals, including prisoners, and it
plays a crucial role in ensuring that those who are incarcerated have access to
justice. The Indian Constitution, through Article 39A, explicitly
mandates free legal aid to the poor and weaker sections of society,
including prisoners, ensuring that justice is not only available but also
accessible to everyone, regardless of their financial status. This is further
reinforced by Articles 14 (right to equality before the law) and 22(1)
(protection against arrest and detention in certain cases), which obligate the
state to uphold fairness and equality within the legal system.
The Justice
A. N. Mulla Committee outlines several rights for prisoners regarding legal
aid, aiming to ensure they have access to the necessary legal support and can
exercise their rights to justice. These rights include:
- Right to Effective Access to
Information: Prisoners must have access to information
regarding the legal provisions that regulate their detention and their
rights within the prison system. This ensures that they are aware of their
legal standing and can act to protect their interests.
- Right to Consult or Be
Defended by a Legal Practitioner of Their Choice:
Prisoners have the right to consult with a lawyer or legal practitioner of
their choosing. This is a critical element in ensuring that they have
effective representation in court and can pursue appeals or other legal
proceedings if necessary.
- Right to Access to Legal
Service Agencies: Prisoners are entitled to
access state-run legal service boards or other agencies providing legal
services. These services are often vital for prisoners who cannot afford
private legal counsel, ensuring they can still pursue justice.
- Right to Information Upon
Admission About Legal Rights: Upon entering prison,
prisoners must be informed of their right to appeal, revision, or review
of their conviction or sentence. This ensures that prisoners are aware of
their options to challenge their imprisonment or sentence, providing an
important safeguard against wrongful detention.
- Right to Receive Court
Documents: Prisoners must be provided with the
necessary court documents to file an appeal, revision, or review of their
case. Without access to these documents, prisoners may be unable to
challenge their conviction or sentence, effectively denying them their
right to justice.
- Right to Present Complaints
and Grievances: Prisoners have the right
to present individual complaints and grievances about their treatment
during confinement. These complaints could pertain to violations of their
rights, inadequate conditions, or mistreatment by prison authorities.
Ensuring that prisoners can voice their concerns is crucial to preventing
abuse and ensuring a fair and just detention process.
- Right to Communicate with
Authorities for Redressal: Prisoners have the right
to communicate with the prison administration, government bodies, and
judicial authorities to seek redressal for any violations of their rights.
This ensures that the prison system is accountable and that prisoners can
take action against any mistreatment or injustice they may experience.
The
situation of women prisoners in India reflects a range of significant
challenges, especially in terms of safety, reformation, and access to justice.
While Tihar Jail in Delhi is often cited as a model for prison reform-offering
access to electronic means for inmates to track their cases, including those in
the Sessions Court, High Court, and even the Supreme Court-such reforms are not
widespread. In many parts of the country, especially in states like Gujarat and
Maharashtra, women prisoners face much harsher conditions, with limited or no
access to information about their legal status or case progress. This knowledge
gap is even more disempowering for women, as it makes understanding and
navigating the legal system a distant reality.
One of
the most concerning issues is the lack of separation between male and female
prisoners in some regions. For instance, in Chhattisgarh, men and women
prisoners are sometimes housed together, despite the obvious risks this poses
to women's safety and dignity. There are also no dedicated women’s prisons in
many states. The one open-air prison for women in Pune remains the only such facility
in the country, highlighting the severe lack of alternatives for female
convicts.
Human
Rights Perspective:
The
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has been instrumental in addressing issues
related to prison administration and the treatment of prisoners, including
those related to women. The court has established some fundamental principles
to ensure the humane treatment of all prisoners, including women:
- A Person in Prison Does Not
Become a Non-Person: This principle asserts
that even though a person is incarcerated, they retain their human
dignity and rights. It underscores that imprisonment should not strip
prisoners of their humanity, and they should continue to be treated with
respect and afforded basic rights.
- A Person in Prison is
Entitled to All Human Rights Within the Limitations of Imprisonment:
This principle reinforces the idea that prisoners do not lose all their
rights while in detention. While certain rights may be restricted due to
the nature of imprisonment, they are still entitled to fundamental human
rights, including the right to safety, access to justice, and humane
treatment.
- There Is No Justification
for Aggravating the Suffering Inherent in Imprisonment:
This principle argues that imprisonment itself is a form of suffering, and
there is no justification for making this suffering worse. Prisons should
be places for reformation and rehabilitation, not for further victimizing
individuals. This principle is particularly important in the context of
women prisoners, who may face additional forms of abuse, discrimination,
and exploitation within the prison system.
Need for
Improved Monitoring and Scrutiny: The case of Ahmedabad Women's
Jail in Gujarat exemplifies the challenges in meeting the needs of pregnant and
nursing women prisoners. While some facilities are available, such as the
provision of basic nutrition, the inconsistent quality and insufficient
quantity of these provisions create serious risks for both the mothers and
children. This situation calls for more rigorous monitoring of prison
conditions, especially in relation to women and children, to ensure that they
are provided with adequate nutrition, healthcare, and emotional support.
Violations
of Dignity and Privacy: In some prisons, offensive and
intrusive body searches are still carried out, violating the privacy and
dignity of women prisoners. These searches are often unnecessary and do not
align with established human rights standards. Furthermore, there is an absence
of alternatives such as body scanners or metal detectors, which could mitigate
the need for invasive searches. The lack of availability or functionality of
these technologies suggests a failure on the part of the authorities to provide
the appropriate tools and practices to respect the dignity of women prisoners. The
Model Prison Manual stipulates that CCTV cameras must be used in a way that
respects the dignity and privacy of women prisoners. And gender sensitization
training for all staff involved in the custody, interrogation, and treatment of
prisoners. This includes raising awareness about human rights and sexual
misconduct.
Scarcity
of Female Jail Staff and Supervisors: One of
the most glaring issues in Indian prisons is the scarcity of female jail staff
and supervisory officers. As of 2015, women comprised only 8.28% of the total
jail staff, a situation that creates significant gaps in the management of
women prisoners. The lack of female staff leads to a situation where male staff
and officials are often responsible for managing women prisoners, which is
highly undesirable and dangerous. This practice increases the vulnerability of
women to harassment and abuse.
Harassment
and Sexual Violence: Another troubling aspect is the
sexual violence and harassment that women prisoners face, often perpetrated by
fellow inmates and sometimes by prison authorities. As highlighted, there are
cases where women are humiliated and violated during body searches, and their
comfort and privacy are routinely disregarded. This systemic abuse can take
many forms, from inappropriate body searches to sexual assault by guards or
male staff members.
The National
Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has recorded 39 cases of rape in
judicial and police custody between 2006 and 2010. This statistic is an
alarming reminder of the lack of safety and protection for women in custody.
Unfortunately, despite such documentation, there has been little monitoring of
conditions in women's prisons, and the system remains largely unchecked. This
has led to continued violations of human rights, with women prisoners
experiencing physical and emotional trauma during their confinement.
Lack of
Specific Medical Support: Another critical concern is the
shortage of medical professionals specifically trained to meet the needs of
women prisoners. There is a particular need for gynecologists and psychologists
in women’s prisons to address issues related to reproductive health, mental
health, and other gender-specific concerns. In the absence of such specialized
care, women prisoners often remain untreated for medical conditions that are
particularly relevant to them. This exacerbates their vulnerability, leaving
them with little recourse for physical and emotional well-being.
The
Unique Challenges Faced by Women Prisoners:
Hormonal Fluctuations:
- Premenstrual
Dysphoric Disorder (PMDD): Women with PMDD may
experience severe mood swings and symptoms similar to irritability,
depression, and anxiety during the premenstrual
phase of their cycle. This can make it difficult to cope with the challenges
of prison life.
- Postpartum
Depression: A mood disorder that can affect women within the first year
after giving birth, characterized by feelings of sadness, hopelessness,
and anxiety.
- Perinatal Mental
Health Issues: A broader term encompassing mental health conditions that
occur during pregnancy or within the first year after childbirth,
including postpartum depression and anxiety.
- Perimenopausal and
Menopausal Depression: Hormonal changes during menopause can contribute to
feelings of depression, anxiety, and irritability.
- PTSD: Women prisoners are
often survivors of trauma, including sexual assault, domestic violence,
and human trafficking. This can lead to PTSD, which can have a significant
impact on their mental and emotional well-being.
Relationship-Related
Issues:
- Intimate Partner
Violence-Related Mental Health Issues: Women who experience intimate
partner violence are at a higher risk of developing mental health
problems, including depression, anxiety, and PTSD.
Body
Image and Self-Esteem:
- Body Image Issues:
Societal pressures and unrealistic beauty standards can contribute to
negative body image and low self-esteem in women.
- Stigma and Discrimination:
Mental health issues are often stigmatized and discriminated against, both
within prisons and in society. This can make it difficult for women
prisoners to seek help or access necessary services.
These
reforms must focus on:
- Ensuring safety from abuse
and exploitation, particularly in mixed-gender prisons or where there are
inadequate security measures.
- Providing education and
vocational training that are more aligned with the realities of women's
post-release lives, helping them reintegrate into society.
- Ensuring access to legal
aid, information about their cases, and avenues to address grievances, so
they can actively participate in their defence and seek redress for
violations of their rights.
- Creating separate facilities
for women prisoners, with proper resources, rehabilitation programs, and
access to healthcare, to ensure their dignity and well-being are
maintained.
The
overall objective should be to empower women prisoners not just by addressing
their immediate needs but by creating an environment that promotes their
long-term rehabilitation, reformation, and reintegration into society,
safeguarding their rights and ensuring their humane treatment throughout their
incarceration.
The issue
of mental illness for women prisoners in India is multifaceted, with
economic, social, and informational barriers significantly hindering their
access to justice. Legal aid services, Medical facilities are though available,
are often underutilized by women prisoners due to a lack of awareness and other
challenges.
Addressing These Challenges:
- Specialized Mental Health
Services: Prisons should have specialized mental health units staffed by
qualified professionals who understand the unique needs of women
prisoners.
- Trauma-Informed Care: Mental
health interventions should be trauma-informed, recognizing the impact of
past experiences on women's mental health.
- Support Groups: Support
groups can provide a safe and supportive space for women prisoners to
share their experiences and receive peer support.
- Advocacy and Awareness:
Raising awareness about mental health issues among women prisoners and
advocating for policy reforms can help to address these challenges.
Counseling
of Women Prisoners and Mental Health Care
The mental
health and well-being of women prisoners are critical aspects that require
focused attention and intervention. Many women who find themselves incarcerated
experience a multitude of challenges - from societal stigma to personal trauma,
both of which contribute to their psychological distress. Given the unique
nature of women's experiences in the criminal justice system, a holistic
approach to mental health and rehabilitation is essential for their recovery
and reintegration into society.
The
counseling of women prisoners must be seen as an ongoing, compassionate, and
essential process that focuses not just on the psychological aspects, but also
on social reintegration and family support. Below are key points that outline
the objectives and approach to counseling women prisoners:
1.
Reframing the Prison Experience
One of
the primary goals of counseling is to help women prisoners view their time in
prison as an opportunity for personal growth and rehabilitation, rather than
simply as a punishment. The idea is to help women understand that prison is not
a "dumping ground" for individuals who are written off by society,
but rather a residential center where they can learn skills, reflect on their
past actions, and work toward their eventual reintegration into society.
Counseling
should help women prisoners to:
- Redefine their purpose: Help
them see prison as a space for self-reflection and growth.
- Understand the process of
rehabilitation: Emphasize that the goal of imprisonment is not solely
punitive but also transformative, preparing them for life outside of
prison.
- Restore hope: Assist them in
seeing that they have the ability to change and re-enter society with a
renewed perspective.
2.
Changing Attitudes Toward Crime and Lawful Living
Women
prisoners often come from backgrounds where they may have been exposed to
violence, abuse, or neglect, all of which can affect their perceptions of crime
and justice. Counseling can help them shift their attitudes by:
- Rectifying pro-crime
attitudes: Many women in prison may have engaged in criminal activities
due to circumstances such as poverty, abuse, or lack of education.
Counseling can help them recognize the root causes of their behavior and
understand the consequences of criminal actions.
- Encouraging lawful behavior:
Counselors can provide guidance on making better choices and embracing a
lifestyle that is respectful of the law and morally sound.
- Instilling a resolve for
reform: Women can be encouraged to take an active role in their own
rehabilitation, with a focus on self-discipline, personal accountability,
and respect for societal norms.
3.
Fostering Self-Realization and Reintegration
Many
women in prison may feel that their past mistakes define them, leading to
feelings of shame or hopelessness. Counseling should be aimed at helping women
recognize that they still possess the qualities and capabilities needed to live
a normal and productive life upon release. Counselors can help them:
- Identify strengths: Help
women realize that they still have the skills, resilience, and potential
to live a meaningful life.
- Develop self-esteem:
Encourage positive self-image and self-worth, which is crucial for
re-entering society.
- Empowerment: Promote
empowerment through education, vocational training, and mental health
support.
- Family and social
reintegration: Involve family members in the rehabilitation process,
encouraging their support for the women’s reintegration and breaking the
societal stigma.
4.
Addressing Trauma and Mental Health Needs
Women in
prison may have undergone trauma such as domestic violence, sexual abuse, or
psychological neglect, all of which contribute to mental health issues.
Comprehensive counseling should include:
- Trauma-informed care:
Counseling should address the trauma that many women in prison experience,
helping them process their experiences and heal from emotional wounds.
- Mental health treatment:
Many women prisoners suffer from depression, anxiety, or post-traumatic
stress disorder (PTSD), and a mental health professional should be
involved in providing appropriate therapies.
- Psychiatric support: Access
to psychiatrists and therapists trained to deal with the particular needs
of incarcerated women should be available to assist them in managing
mental health issues.
5.
Long-Term Rehabilitation and Support
Counseling
should not end when women are released from prison; rather, it should be part
of a long-term rehabilitation plan that includes:
- Post-release support:
Programs that provide continued mental health counseling, vocational
training, and social reintegration support.
- Family counseling: Often,
women prisoners are estranged from their families or face difficulty
reuniting due to societal stigmas. Providing family counseling can
facilitate reconciliation and support during reintegration.
- Community programs: Engaging
women in community-based rehabilitation programs can help them reinforce
their commitment to leading a law-abiding life and build supportive social
networks.
6.
Encouraging Participation in Group Therapy and Peer Support
Many women
prisoners benefit from group therapy or peer support groups, where they can:
- Share experiences: Engage
with others who have similar life challenges and criminal backgrounds,
which can help build mutual support networks.
- Learn from others: Gain
strength and inspiration from others who are working on their own
rehabilitation journeys.
- Develop communication
skills: Through interaction with other inmates, women can improve their
social skills, which will be essential when reintegrating into society.
Project ‘KIRAN’ and Initiatives for Reform
In
response to these issues, Project KIRAN was launched in Odisha in 2021 as a
significant step toward addressing the specific needs of women prisoners.
Project KIRAN is a help desk initiative that provides free legal aid,
rehabilitation, and mental health counseling to women prisoners. The project
was initiated by the Directorate of Prisons and Correctional Services, in
partnership with the Odisha-based NGO MAADHYAM, and aims to empower women
prisoners by providing them with essential services and support.
This
initiative reflects a growing recognition of the unique challenges faced by
female inmates and the urgent need for targeted support to help them
reintegrate into society after their release.
Conclusion
The women
prisoners are to be treated with respect, dignity, and humanity, and that they
are not subjected to further abuse or neglect during their time in prison. Counseling
plays a crucial role in the rehabilitation of women prisoners, helping them
overcome past trauma, develop a positive attitude toward lawful living, and
build the confidence necessary for reintegration into society. A comprehensive,
holistic approach to mental health and family counseling is essential for
breaking the cycle of crime and fostering successful reintegration into
society. With proper counseling, women prisoners can find healing, empowerment,
and the tools to lead a productive, law-abiding life after their release. Addressing
the information gap, economic barriers, and social stigma is crucial to
ensuring that women in prison are given the chance to rebuild their lives
post-incarceration.
Despite
the Supreme Court's directives, many prisons in India still fail to meet the
specific needs of pregnant and nursing women and their children. The lack of
proper facilities for children, insufficient nutrition, and inadequate
healthcare contribute to the vulnerability of both mothers and children in
these prisons. While Tihar Jail serves as an example of what is possible when
guidelines are followed, there is a need for systematic implementation across
the country to ensure that all women prisoners, especially those who are
pregnant or nursing, receive the support and care they require. The rigorous
monitoring and scrutiny of prison conditions are essential to make this a
reality.
Bottom of Form
